10 Best Restaurants in Long Island for 2024

Long Island is a culinary destination that offers a variety of cuisines, from classic American to exotic Asian, from casual to fine dining. Whether you are looking for a romantic date night, a family-friendly outing, or a solo adventure, you will find a restaurant that suits your taste and budget in Long Island. In this blog post, we will introduce you to 10 of the best restaurants in Long Island for 2024, based on their food quality, service, atmosphere, and reviews. These restaurants are not ranked in any particular order, but they are all worth a visit. Let’s get started!

1. Verona Ristorante

Verona Ristorante is an acclaimed Italian restaurant in Farmingdale that excels in Italian countryside cuisine as well as Italian dining with international flavors. The menu features a variety of dishes, from salads and soups to pasta and pizza, from chicken and veal to seafood and steak. Some of the signature dishes include the lobster ravioli, the chicken Verona, the veal saltimbocca, and the filet mignon. The restaurant also offers a wine shop, where you can buy a bottle of wine to pair with your meal or take home. The ambiance is cozy and elegant, with a fireplace, a brick wall, and a chandelier. The service is friendly and attentive, and the prices are reasonable. Verona Ristorante is a great place to enjoy authentic Italian food in a warm and welcoming setting 1

2. The LakeHouse

The LakeHouse is a New American fine dining lakeside restaurant that features bayside dining. The restaurant is located on the Great South Bay in Bay Shore, and offers stunning views of the water and the sunset. The menu showcases seasonal and local ingredients, and changes frequently to reflect the availability and freshness of the produce. Some of the dishes you can expect to find include the roasted beet salad, the lobster bisque, the scallop and shrimp risotto, the duck breast, and the rack of lamb. The restaurant also has an extensive wine list, a cocktail menu, and a dessert menu. The atmosphere is romantic and sophisticated, with a fireplace, a piano, and a candlelit dining room. The service is professional and courteous, and the prices are on the higher end. The LakeHouse is a perfect place to celebrate a special occasion or treat yourself to a memorable dining experience 2

3. Restaurant Joanina

Restaurant Joanina is a rustic Italian eating house with a Tuscan motif that presents Italian classics and a wine shop. The restaurant is located in Huntington, and has been serving the community since 1992. The menu offers a range of dishes, from antipasti and salads to pasta and pizza, from chicken and veal to fish and steak. Some of the popular dishes include the fried calamari, the gnocchi al pesto, the chicken parmigiana, and the veal marsala. The restaurant also has a wine shop, where you can buy a bottle of wine to complement your meal or take home. The ambiance is cozy and charming, with a brick oven, a wooden bar, and a mural. The service is friendly and efficient, and the prices are moderate. Restaurant Joanina is a wonderful place to enjoy traditional Italian food in a quaint and cozy setting 3

4. Maureen’s Kitchen

Maureen’s Kitchen is a family-owned and operated American diner that specializes in breakfast and brunch. The restaurant is located in Smithtown, and has been serving the community since 1982. The menu features a variety of dishes, from pancakes and waffles to omelets and sandwiches, from burgers and wraps to salads and soups. Some of the signature dishes include the banana walnut pancakes, the corned beef hash omelet, the French toast sandwich, and the turkey club. The restaurant also offers daily specials, such as the pumpkin pancakes, the apple pie waffle, and the spinach and feta omelet. The ambiance is casual and quirky, with a cow theme, a chalkboard menu, and a gift shop. The service is friendly and fast, and the prices are reasonable. Maureen’s Kitchen is a fun and delicious place to start your day or enjoy a midday meal 4

5. Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner

Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner is a classic American diner that serves breakfast and lunch. The restaurant is located in Carle Place, and has been serving the community since 1946. The menu offers a variety of dishes, from eggs and bacon to pancakes and French toast, from burgers and hot dogs to sandwiches and salads. Some of the specialty dishes include the eggs Benedict, the Belgian waffle, the Monte Cristo sandwich, and the Reuben. The restaurant also offers homemade pies, cakes, and muffins. The ambiance is retro and nostalgic, with a jukebox, a counter, and a neon sign. The service is friendly and attentive, and the prices are affordable. Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner is a great place to enjoy a hearty and satisfying meal in a vintage and cozy setting 5

6. The Bryant

The Bryant is a modern American steakhouse that offers a refined and elegant dining experience. The restaurant is located in Garden City, and is part of the Poll Restaurants group. The menu features a selection of prime steaks, chops, and seafood, as well as appetizers, salads, sides, and desserts. Some of the dishes you can expect to find include the crab cake, the wedge salad, the filet mignon, the porterhouse, the lobster tail, and the chocolate cake. The restaurant also has a full bar, a wine list, and a cocktail menu. The atmosphere is sophisticated and stylish, with a fireplace, a lounge, and a private dining room. The service is impeccable and courteous, and the prices are on the higher end. The Bryant is a superb place to indulge in a fine and exquisite meal in a classy and upscale setting 6

7. Rumba

Rumba is a Caribbean-inspired restaurant and rum bar that offers a tropical and lively dining experience. The restaurant is located in Hampton Bays, and overlooks the Shinnecock Bay. The menu features a variety of dishes, from tacos and empanadas to salads and sandwiches, from jerk chicken and ribs to fish and shrimp. Some of the dishes you can expect to find include the coconut shrimp, the jerk chicken Caesar salad, the pulled pork sandwich, the fish tacos, and the rum cake. The restaurant also has a rum bar, where you can enjoy a selection of rum cocktails, such as the mojito, the daiquiri, and the piña colada. The atmosphere is fun and festive, with a beachy decor, a live music, and a deck. The service is friendly and energetic, and the prices are moderate. Rumba is a fantastic place to have a fun and flavorful meal in a tropical and vibrant setting.

8. Crabtree’s Restaurant

Crabtree’s Restaurant is a Mediterranean-inspired restaurant that offers a cozy and intimate dining experience. The restaurant is located in Floral Park, and has been serving the community since 1983. The menu features a variety of dishes, from appetizers and soups to pasta and risotto, from chicken and veal to fish and lamb. Some of the dishes you can expect to find include the stuffed mushrooms, the lobster bisque, the penne alla vodka, the chicken francese, and the lamb chops. The restaurant also offers a wine list, a dessert menu, and a catering service. The atmosphere is warm and romantic, with a fireplace, a brick wall, and a mural. The service is friendly and professional, and the prices are reasonable. Crabtree’s Restaurant is a lovely place to enjoy a delicious and cozy meal in a warm and romantic setting.

9. Vespa Italian Chop House

Vespa Italian Chop House is an Italian-American restaurant that offers a contemporary and chic dining experience. The restaurant is located in Farmingdale, and is part of the Vespa group. The menu features a variety of dishes, from antipasti and salads to pasta and pizza, from chicken and veal to chops and steaks. Some of the dishes you can expect to find include the fried calamari, the Caesar salad, the linguine with clam sauce, the chicken Vespa, and the ribeye steak. The restaurant also has a full bar, a wine list, and a cocktail menu. The atmosphere is modern and sleek, with a wood-fired oven, a marble bar, and a chandelier. The service is friendly and attentive, and the prices are moderate. Vespa Italian Chop House is a wonderful place to enjoy a modern and sleek meal in a contemporary and chic setting.

10. Cafe Baci

Cafe Baci is a casual Italian restaurant that offers a relaxed and family-friendly dining experience. The restaurant is located in Westbury, and has been serving the community since 1993. The menu features a variety of dishes, from appetizers and soups to pasta and pizza, from chicken and veal to fish and steak. Some of the dishes you can expect to find include the bruschetta, the minestrone soup, the fettuccine Alfredo, the chicken parmigiana, and the salmon. The restaurant also offers a wine list, a dessert menu, and a catering service. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with a brick oven, a mural, and a fountain. The service is friendly and accommodating, and the prices are reasonable.